Prosecutorial Discretion : Does it work?
Many if our clients have been calling to inquire if they should indeed go for the prosecutorial discretion route. As always I give my answer depending on the facts of the case. Consider Amy who is in court proceedings because United States CItizenship and Immigration Services( USCIS) denied the I-130 petition of her husband.
Amy filed an appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals but the appeal is still pending. The immigration Judge has graciously granted Amy a few continuances awaiting the final decision on the appeal. Amy has been married for over ten years and has a valid marriage. But for whatever reason USCIS is not convinced that the marriage is a true and real. Now Amy's husband, the petitioner has been diagnosed with cancer. What should she do? Well the stress of court is getting to her and plus she has has the pressure of taking care of her husband. I think in this situation Amy should apply for prosecutorial discretion since we have no way of knowing how long the appeal process will take. In addition, Amy can always reopen her case with the Immigration Court once her appeal is decided.
Amy has to be sure to document her case properly for the the Department of Homeland Security. She has to be sure to submit to the DHS, all medical records of her husband. She also needs to submit proof that theirs is a good bona fide marriage.
Many of our legal analysts have said that the process does not help. I beg to differ. We are finally giving a chance to people to stay in the United States even if the Immigration Judge in his or her discretion decides that a case is not approvable. Let us now wait for the USCIS to comply and issue the oh so needed work permit.
Prosecutorial discretion is not for everyone. If you have a strong case for cancellation of removal or other forms of relief then by all means proceed with your case which may lead to permanent residence. But speak to your attorney first.